RECLAIMING PAVEMENTS IN THAILAND, SINGAPORE
The Saigon campaign was similar to the one carried out in Thailand in October 2016 when it sought to reclaim the pavements near major tourist attractions around the Grand Palace and Huai Kwang Market extending from Pracha Uthit to Pracha Songkhro Roads. City authorities also went on to clear Bangkok’s Sukhumvit Road, the so-called ‘golden mile’ of the city’s tourist areas. The street vendors were moved, although this still requires constant monitoring by the city’s municipal police to ensure the streets remain uncongested. Although tourists have complained that the streets had lost their appeal, residents have welcomed the absence of hawkers, peddlers and motorcycle taxis along the pavements. Nevertheless, the government went on to refine the program to allow pavement food stores to operate on the streets or in the alleys provided they do not interfere with pedestrian access.
Photo Credit: news.zing.vn
Sixty years ago, Singapore decided to clean up its pavements and activities that were carried out along the city’s streets. To retain the culture of the local hawker scene and help the affected peddlers, designated ‘food streets’ were created for locals and tourists to enjoy. The streets are closed to traffic at certain times, which enables people to eat in comfort as well as walk around freely. The government also built markets and issued licenses to street vendors, which meant they could now operate legally. Vendors are required to comply with food safety standards and are tasked with maintaining a clean and safe environment. If this approach is studied further and applied in HCMC, the authors believe it would spice up city life as well as bring about positive change in the life of residents.
Singapore also developed an efficient transport system, tightened measures for private vehicle ownership, and made the well-connected public bus and train system a key means of local transportation. Most residents live in apartments and shop in malls, unlike those in HCMC, where residents live in houses and use their properties as offices, restaurants and stores. This sees the vehicles of residents parked along the pavements, contributing to congestion. The city’s weak public transportation system and constant housing construction also means it will take a very long time to clear the pavements.
EFFECTIVE URBAN MANAGEMENT
Singapore and Thailand have developed appropriate policies that have been refined to reflect adjustments needed in their respective communities. Learning from their experiences as well as developing suitable negotiation and management strategies to engage street vendors will boost HCMC’s socio-economic development as well as change the shopping behaviour of its residents. Instead of prohibiting street vendor activities, for example, HCMC authorities should consider creation of designated areas for food stalls to allow them to operate hygienically and safely. This not only helps in urban management and planning of the city landscape, it also allows the mostly immigrant stall owners to make a living.
The campaign did not receive much support from owners of stores and street vendors. Their businesses slowed due to the absence of parking spaces and after the campaign was over, several businesses resumed their activities along the pavements. For its part, the government could have softened the approach it used in the campaign, as well as given affected businesses sufficient prior notification of the clean up in order not to take them by surprise. Further, in order to achieve a better outcome, local authorities should have also considered involving business owners in the process in order to obtain different or innovative approaches. One example might be to allow street vendors to rent a site on the pavement to sell their products during designated hours. This would have seen all parties enjoy the best of both worlds: sustainable commerce and clean streets.
Authors: Phuong V. Nguyen is a lecturer at International University, VNU-HCMC. Tran Thi Ngoc Vo is currently studying for a bachelor of arts at International University, VNU-HCMC.
- Mike Ives, Efforts to Ease Congestion Threaten Street Food Culture in Southeast Asia, ”NY Times”, April 29, 2017, https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/29/world/asia/sidewalk-food-vendors-hanoi-bangkok-jakarta.html?_r=0
- The Nation, Two months ago Vietnam cleared its street vendors. Here’s what happened, April 21, 2017, http://www.nationmultimedia.com/news/opinion/30312862
- Citypassguide (2017), Is Sidewalk culture at risk in HCMC, "https://www.citypassguide.com/en/living/ho-chi-minh-city/working/blog/is-sidewalk-culture-at-risk-in-hcmc"m/en/living/ho-chi-minh-city/working/blog/is-sidewalk-culture-at-risk-in-hcmc
- VN Express (2017), What the future holds for Vietnam’s street vendors, http://e.vnexpress.net/projects/sidewalk-economics-what-the-future-holds-for-vietnam-s-ubiquitous-street-vendors-3565620/index.html